MobileDo App Interstitials Create A Bad User Experience?

Do App Interstitials Create A Bad User Experience?

Google research says yes, counting the ad format among negative ranking factors. However, Yelp's CEO - and industry experts - remains skeptical of the company's reasoning.

Google may denounce mobile app interstitials, but according to Yelp chief executive (CEO) Jeremy Stoppelman, that may be because apps pose a threat to the company’s search business.

Last month, Google published research on its own interstitials with the Google+ mobile site and found that 9 percent of users actually clicked the “Get App” button, while 69 percent abandoned the page altogether. After replacing the interstitial with a less in-your-face Smart App Banner, Google saw one-day active users on the mobile site increase by 17 percent. Per Google’s mobile SEO guide, which advises advertisers to stay away, “In extreme cases, the interstitial is designed to make it very difficult for the user to dismiss it and view the real content of the page. Since screen real-estate on mobile devices is limited, any interstitial negatively impacts the user’s experience.”

AJ Ghergich, founder of content marketing agency Ghergich & Co., says that regarding this research, it’s important to consider the source and the product.

“Maybe people just didn’t want to download Google+; it’s not like it’s a huge success, so is it shocking people aren’t downloading the app in droves?” Ghergich says. “The engineer from Google makes a dangerous assumption that your results will be similar to his single test. Google’s hope ‘that you will reconsider the use of promotional interstitials’ is ridiculous if it’s based on a single failed test.”

In a guest post on Search Engine Land yesterday, Stoppelman pointed out that Google still employs the full-page interstitial method for promoting apps such as Gmail and Google Maps. Playing off a Steve Jobs quote, the CEO noted that in order for people to use apps – which, according to comScore, account for seven of every eight minutes the average user spends consuming media – they have to be able to discover the apps and know they exist.

“After users cross the bridge from mobile Web to apps, they likely don’t go back,” Stoppelman wrote. “This presents an existential threat to Google’s core business of search, which envisions Google as the ‘middleman’ for all information transactions on the Internet. Apps disintermediate, or in plain English, remove the middleman and allow the consumer to interact directly with the developer.”

Stoppelman added that when interstitials are annoying, it’s because of the developers behind them more than the ad format being inherently disruptive. Sam Hurley, head of search at U.K. digital agency Midas Media, points out that while interstitials may not be inherently disruptive, they are inherently interruptive – which isn’t necessarily a bad thing.

“Let’s face it: full-screen interruptive marketing is always going to foster negative feedback. However, the effectiveness of such advertising is to be reckoned with. Frustrating as these ads may be, the user has no option but to digest the information presented to them,” Hurley says, mentioning the power of visual recall.

Like Stoppelman, Hurley finds Google’s research self-serving and biased. “I’d personally discount this information purely due to the amount of variables which come into play,” he says. “A fair test demands a multi-faceted approach, not a sweeping statement derived from a single experiment using a single app and product.”

Related Articles

Video marketing tips and tools to boost your traffic

Mobile Video marketing tips and tools to boost your traffic

8m Nat McNeely
Progressive web apps (PWAs) for SEO: Benefits, stats, examples

Development Progressive web apps (PWAs) for SEO: Benefits, stats, examples

11m Rohan Ayyar
How to optimize paid search ads for phone calls

Local How to optimize paid search ads for phone calls

11m Emily Alford
Why mobile first design is the only 2019 strategy that will work

Mobile Why mobile first design is the only 2019 strategy that will work

1y Adam Enfroy
Top trends to increase value for paid search spend

Mobile Top trends to increase value for paid search spend

1y Kenneth Andrew
Google Ads 2019: What to look out for

Industry Google Ads 2019: What to look out for

1y Mike Ncube
Mobile search and video in 2019: How visible are you?

Mobile Mobile search and video in 2019: How visible are you?

1y Luke Richards
The Page Speed update: what SEOs need to know

Mobile The Page Speed update: what SEOs need to know

2y Aleh Barysevich

Resources

SEO for Website Redesign and Migration

SEO SEO for Website Redesign and Migration

6m
Ever-Changing GoalPosts - SEO Challenges and How to Overcome Them

Analytics Ever-Changing GoalPosts - SEO Challenges and How to Overcome Them

6m
7 Unexpected PPC + SEO Strategies for Growth Marketing

Content 7 Unexpected PPC + SEO Strategies for Growth Marketing

6m
All About Click Fraud and How You Can Block It

PPC All About Click Fraud and How You Can Block It

8m